Three factors decide the choice — the type of candle, the diameter and the wax. Weigh them together, then confirm with a burn test: there is no universal rule.
The most important factor. Always measure the inner diameter of the container, wall to wall. Manufacturer charts are for plain candles, without fragrance or dye: with a fragranced vegetable wax, expect to go 1 to 2 sizes up from the generic chart — and more in difficult combinations.


Wooden wicks: they crackle, never slump and leave no unpleasant smell when put out — but they are the hardest to get right. Read our wooden wick guide ›
The right wick only works if it is fitted properly. These details make a real difference to the burn.

An off-centre wick burns one side only and, in extreme cases, overheats the glass until it cracks. Use a wick centring tool and keep the wick taut while the wax sets.

Keep the metal sustainer at the bottom: it holds the wick upright and stops the flame reaching the base. Fix it with wick stickers or with a thin layer (about 1 mm) of wax poured first.
Cut the wick to about 5 mm before lighting. Trim when the wax is cold; straighten the wick while it is still soft. Put the candle out with a snuffer rather than blowing — less smoke and soot.

Add 5–10% vegetable stearin to soft vegetable waxes: it hardens the wax and stops the wooden wick going out. See stearin.
Direction matters: fit braided wicks with the “V” of the braid opening upwards, towards the tip of the candle.
The maximum load a wax accepts is rarely needed. Most fragrances perform well between 6 and 10%; too much fragrance clogs the wick and makes soot without improving the throw.
Usually a wick set too loosely or not held while the wax set.
The flame draws up more fuel (wax + fragrance + dye) than it can burn. A pool deeper than 15 mm after 30 minutes is a clear sign.
The pool widens about 2–3 cm per hour — give it time first. Rarely, a wick that is too big also tunnels.
Blowing the flame out sends up smoke and soot from the glowing wick.
Compare your candle’s flame with these illustrations to identify the problem.

The wick rises straight and curves to the edge of the flame, where it burns away completely at the highest temperature.

Uneven tension in the braid, or strands twisted before the wick was fitted.

Flame too large for the diameter, with soot. → Go down one size.

It does not curl, so the tip never reaches the hottest zone and mushrooms. Cause: paper threads in the core, or hard waxes, additives, dyes and fragrances clogging it.

It melts more wax than it can burn; the pool fills up and may overflow. → Go up one size.

The wick was set too loosely or had too much room when pouring. → Centre it and keep it taut.

Damaged by impurities (pigments, synthetic waxes, fragrance): the flame shrinks and the candle may go out.

This smoke comes from draughts. → Burn the candle away from draughts.

Soft paraffin or a wick without the right treatment; common in pressed candles.

Impurities in the wax collect at the tip as threads, sometimes like a second wick.

Illustrations and technical information: WEDO wicks (wedobraids.com)
Choose your wax and diameter in our wick calculator.
The test at a glance: three identical candles — the recommended wick (✓), one size down (−1) and one up (+1) — at 20–25 °C, at least 10 cm apart, in 4-hour cycles.
Each series is built for a type of wax. Knowing how it is made helps you understand why the calculator recommends it.

Flat-braided cotton with paper filaments, coated for rigidity. Unbleached and with no chemical treatment. It curls slightly at the tip, which reduces mushrooming, smoke and soot. NAT is the same wick coated in vegetable wax: wherever one works, so does the other. Both are made in Europe, comply with REACH and RAL-GZ 041 and contain no SVHC substances such as boric acid or borax; the cotton is OEKO-TEX® 100 certified.

Coreless flat braid in cotton with paper filaments, pre-waxed at a high temperature. It curls into the hottest part of the flame and burns cleanly.

Coreless flat braid with stabilising threads that keep a slight curl. It gives a controlled flame: the glass does not overheat on one side and pillars do not blow out through the wall.

High-grade cotton with white stabilising filaments — the wick stays white in the candle. Treated to cope with solid colours and fragrance loads up to about 10%.
Sources: HowtoMakeCandles.info, Rustic Escentuals, Atkins & Pearce, Wedo and Monterosa Zelandi.
With a wooden wick, the width is chosen by the container diameter and the thickness by the wax. A wick too wide or too narrow leads to tunnelling, soot and smoke.
| Inner diameter | Reference width | In our shop |
|---|---|---|
| 38–51 mm | 6.4 mm | EA 1 / EC 1 · 8 mm (our narrowest) |
| 51–64 mm | 9.5 mm | EA 2 / EC 2 · 10 mm |
| 64–76 mm | 12.7 mm | EA 3 / EC 3 · 12 mm |
| 76–89 mm | 15.9 mm | EA 4 / EC 4 · 14 mm or EA 5 / EC 5 · 16 mm |
| above 89 mm | 19 mm or more | use 2 wicks |
Reference widths: Wooden Wick Co. They are a starting point — always confirm with a burn test.

